Comic fans can finally stop holding their breath: If the reviews are to be believed, it looks like Marvel and director Jon Favreau got Iron Man right. Things looked to be headed in the right direction the moment Robert Downey Jr. was cast as Tony Stark (and not this guy), but once you factor in how many people have their say on such a multimillion dollar production, it’s a wonder there’s any personality left over once the film goes through the entire production process.
I won’t find out until tomorrow if "Iron Man" joins the ranks of the great superhero movies, but at least I’m pretty sure he won’t rocket-boot his way to the bottom of the line with the rest of the losers (no, not these Losers).
My Favorite Superhero Movies
Superman II (1980)
Yes, they took it away from Richard Donner. Yes, the “comedy” bits are lame. Yes, the deus ex smooch at the end is a giant cheat. Yes, it’s cheesy as hell. But darn it if the Superman sequel isn’t the best superhero movie ever. It’s got heart, action, a fantastic villain AND Superman gets lucky. Granted, it’s with Margo Kidder but I’d still pick her wiseacre Lois Lane over the dull Kate Bosworth version.
Spider-Man 2 (2004)
Much like in "Superman II," now that we’ve got all the messy exposition out of the way, "Spider-Man 2" is free to tell an interesting story (why, oh why must all superhero movies be origin stories? If you can believe a man can fly, does it matter how or why?). After the solid but uninspired first film, director Sam Raimi came back with a new sense of fun and a strong script that found the right balance between action and character.
Alfred Molina as Doc Ock is a great sympathetic villain and the sequence were Peter stops the runaway subway car perfectly distills Spider-Man’s appeal down to its essence. Spider-Man is not Superman and he’s a better character because of it.
Unbreakable (2000)
I know I just complained about origin stories, but it helps that you don’t realize you’re watching one until the third act of M. Night Shyamalan’s perfectly paced, real-world superhero tale. Heartbreaking or empowering, depending on which character’s point of view you take, “Unbreakable” was seen as too mopey by many audiences but it’s really a celebration of comic book dreams.
X2: X-Men United (2003)
Looks like second time’s the charm for most of these movies. "X-Men 2" builds on the first film (again, solid but uninspired) and manages not to insult comics fans and still be interesting and easy to follow for mainstream audiences. Good character development, exciting action sequences and a cliffhanger ending make the movie work. Much like "Spider-Man 2," it’s so good that it promised a sequel that it didn’t deliver on.
Batman Begins (2005)
You know you’ve got a good movie when the title character doesn’t show up until the middle of the film and you’re so caught up with other things that you could have done without him. In fact, if anything is weak in this movie (apart from Katie Holmes’ limp performance) is that Christian Bale is so strong as Bruce Wayne that you miss him when he turns into Batman. Other than that, director Christopher Nolan revives the franchise with style and wit. He gives the Dark Knight his balls back, after being thoroughly neutered by Joel Schumacher.
Honorable mentions
Hulk (2003)
Ang Lee’s misunderstood monster movie turns a father/son psychological battle into the Hulk fighting a dust storm Nick Nolte (or something like that).
The Rocketeer (1991)
Maybe it’s the beautiful Jennifer Connely, or maybe it’s the beautiful Rocketeer design, or maybe it’s the beautiful fact that nobody saw it, whatever the reason, “The Rocketeer” has a special place on this list.
Terrible superhero movies
Batman Forever (1995)
George Clooney likes to apologize for “Batman & Robin,” but that movie was at least tolerable because you went in knowing what to expect. “Batman Forever,” the first of Joel Schumacher’s roundhouse buggerings of the Batman franchise, is the one people should be put in prison for. While Val Kilmer and Nicole Kidman sleepwalk through it, Tommy Lee Jones and Jim Carrey chew up the scenery, puke it back up and then make the audience eat it.
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen (2003)
Next to “Watchmen Babies in V for Vacation,” this movie is probably the worst adaptation of an Alan Moore comic that I can think of. The concept for Gentlemen is simple, it’s Justice League meets Victorian Literature as Mina Murray, Allan Quatermain, Captain Nemo, Mr. Hyde and the Invisible Man join forces to stop a nefarious threat against the empire.
In the hands of Moore and Kevin O’Neill, the comic is packed with atmosphere and dense with period references and allusions. In the hands of the Hollywood dumbasses who “adapted” it, it’s basically full of crap.
Spawn (1997)
A visionary film, in so far as it predicted that the comic book would eventually be as terrible as the movie.
Catwoman (2004)
Seriously, I had trouble with Michelle Pfeiffer’s Catwoman in “Batman Returns,” but I would rather be whipped by her while stitching together her ridiculous patchwork leather outfit than to sit through Halle Berry’s take on the character ever again.
Lamestrosities
- Elektra
- Ghost Rider
- Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer
- Spider-Man 3
- X-Men: The Last Stand
- Superman III and IV
Recent Comments